It Could Have Been Her

About It Could Have Been Her audiobook

Listen on Audible for free
Try for 30 days, you can cancel whenever you want

Lisa Jewell Returns to the Psychological Suspense That Made Her a Bestseller

Over the past decade, Lisa Jewell has quietly become one of the defining voices in contemporary psychological suspense. While her early career was built on relationship-driven contemporary fiction—including her bestselling debut Ralph's Party—her transition into darker, intricately plotted thrillers transformed her into an international phenomenon. Novels such as Then She Was Gone, The Family Upstairs, The Night She Disappeared, None of This Is True, and Don't Let Him In established a signature style built on ordinary people caught inside deeply unsettling mysteries, where seemingly insignificant moments eventually unravel into devastating truths.

It Could Have Been Her feels like a natural continuation of that evolution. Rather than reinventing her formula, Jewell refines it once again, delivering a psychological thriller that thrives on creeping tension, emotional vulnerability, and the unsettling realization that one random decision can echo across decades.

The premise is classic Lisa Jewell: deceptively simple, immediately unsettling, and loaded with questions that refuse to leave the listener's mind.

A Chance Encounter Becomes a Twenty-Five-Year Obsession

The novel opens with a memory that refuses to fade.

Freshly divorced and emotionally adrift, Jane Trevally accepts an invitation from a man she barely knows to visit his isolated house on Hampstead Heath. What initially seems like an awkward but harmless encounter suddenly turns sinister when Jane hears a scream from upstairs. Instinct takes over. She runs without looking back.

It's a brief episode—one that could easily have become another forgotten near miss—but Jewell understands how a single unresolved moment can linger beneath the surface of a life.

Twenty-five years later, Jane unexpectedly finds herself standing outside that very same house after returning a lost white dog to its owner. The owner has just been reported missing, and a fleeting glimpse of a frightened woman watching from an upstairs window awakens memories Jane thought she'd buried forever.

From there, Jewell slowly pulls both Jane and the audience into a mystery that stretches across generations, revealing that the terrifying night Jane escaped may have been only one chapter in a much larger story.

Lisa Jewell Excels at Building Suspense Through Character

One of Jewell's greatest strengths has always been her ability to create suspense without relying solely on plot twists.

Her novels rarely begin with shocking murders or explosive action. Instead, they introduce emotionally believable people whose lives gradually become entangled with secrets they never intended to uncover. The suspense grows not because events become louder, but because each new revelation quietly changes the meaning of everything that came before.

It Could Have Been Her follows that familiar rhythm beautifully.

Jane isn't portrayed as an amateur detective searching for excitement. She's simply someone who cannot ignore the feeling that she narrowly escaped something unimaginable decades earlier. That emotional grounding makes her investigation feel personal rather than procedural, allowing the mystery to unfold with the slow-burning intensity that has become Jewell's trademark.

As always, the author demonstrates remarkable patience. Rather than rushing toward major revelations, she carefully layers small details, subtle clues, and shifting perspectives until the larger picture gradually comes into focus.

A Full-Cast Audiobook That Elevates Every Perspective

Penguin's audiobook production embraces one of the novel's biggest strengths: its multiple viewpoints.

Instead of relying on a single narrator, It Could Have Been Her features an impressive ensemble cast led by Lesley Sharp and James Norton, alongside Joanna David, Emilia Fox, Freddie Fox, Tim McInnerny, Ella Rae Smith, Harriet Fisher, Elsa Lepecki Bean, and Roy McMillan.

The decision pays off immediately.

Each narrator gives their character a distinct emotional identity, making perspective shifts feel natural rather than confusing. Conversations gain additional dramatic weight, while internal monologues retain an intimacy that might have been diluted in a single-voice production.

Lesley Sharp anchors the audiobook with warmth and quiet vulnerability, perfectly capturing Jane's mixture of determination and lingering fear. James Norton brings a measured intensity to his chapters, while the supporting cast enriches the listening experience by making every voice feel genuinely individual.

At just under eleven hours, the audiobook maintains an excellent pace, balancing moments of psychological tension with quieter scenes that allow listeners to absorb the growing emotional complexity of the story.

Familiar Themes, Fresh Execution

Fans of None of This Is True will immediately recognize many of the themes that have come to define Jewell's recent work.

She remains fascinated by hidden lives, dangerous houses, fractured identities, unreliable appearances, and the lasting consequences of trauma. Her stories often suggest that evil doesn't always arrive dramatically—it frequently hides behind ordinary neighborhoods, polite conversations, and familiar faces.

The isolated Hampstead house becomes far more than a setting. Like the Chelsea home in The Family Upstairs, it develops into a character in its own right, filled with memories, unanswered questions, and invisible scars left behind by those who lived within its walls.

Jewell also continues to explore coincidence in fascinating ways. Random encounters rarely remain random in her novels; instead, they become the invisible threads connecting strangers whose lives were destined to intersect long before they realized it.

A Thriller That Rewards Patient Listeners

Unlike faster-paced crime novels that prioritize relentless action, It Could Have Been Her trusts its audience to appreciate gradual storytelling.

The mystery unfolds methodically, allowing tension to accumulate almost imperceptibly before accelerating toward its final revelations. Every seemingly minor conversation, every uncomfortable silence, and every lingering memory contributes to an atmosphere where uncertainty becomes almost unbearable.

Listeners expecting constant twists from beginning to end may find the opening deliberately restrained. Those willing to embrace Jewell's carefully measured pacing, however, will discover exactly what has made her one of the most reliable names in psychological suspense.

A Worthy Successor to Lisa Jewell's Recent Bestsellers

It Could Have Been Her doesn't attempt to radically reinvent Lisa Jewell's formula—and it doesn't need to. Instead, it builds confidently upon everything that has made her recent novels so compelling: psychologically rich characters, elegantly layered mysteries, emotionally resonant storytelling, and an extraordinary ability to make ordinary situations feel profoundly unsettling.

The outstanding full-cast narration only strengthens the experience, transforming an already immersive thriller into one of the year's most engaging audiobooks.

For longtime fans, this feels like another confident entry in Jewell's remarkable run of bestselling psychological suspense. For newcomers, it's an excellent introduction to an author who has mastered the art of turning everyday lives into unforgettable mysteries, proving once again that the most frightening stories are often the ones that begin with a single decision—and the haunting realization that, under slightly different circumstances, it could have been you.

This content contains affiliate links. When you buy through these links, we may earn an affiliate commission.