The Girl in the Blue Mustang

NBC News

When 18-year-old Michelle O’Keefe is found murdered in her shiny new blue Mustang in a California park and ride, investigators encounter a confusing crime scene and a witness who seems to know too much. Read more

True crime Murder Mystery

Episodes

Dateline Presents: Trace of Suspicion

03/10/2026 00:04:17Introducing: Trace of Suspicion

03/03/2026 00:02:59 6 - Finding John Doe

04/11/2023 00:36:495 - Revelations

04/04/2023 00:30:594 - One Buzz. Then Another.

03/28/2023 00:35:34 Show all episodes

Our take on The Girl in the Blue Mustang podcast

The Girl in the Blue Mustang podcast tells the story of the murder of 18-year-old Michelle O'Keefe in California. Keith Morrison takes you on a journey through the confusing crime scene and suspicious witness accounts in each weekly episode. What sets this true crime series apart is the involvement of a Dateline observant who drives the case in a new direction, with twists and turns at every corner. The Girl in the Blue Mustang is a true crime podcast by NBC News.